When Police Search and Seize Privileged Communications

Police searches are typically very broad. That’s because when police are conducting a legal search of someone’s home, car, business, or the person themselves, they are not always sure of what they are going to find. As a result, police often collect a lot of documents, things, and information that do not relate to the suspected crime.

What happens, though, if the search leads to the police getting access to legally privileged information? Specifically, communications between an attorney and their client about a legal matter?

Attorney-Client Communications Are Privileged

Indiana law protects attorney-client communications in a number of ways. Attorneys cannot be required to testify about confidential client communications and advice they give to clients. They have a legal obligation to keep confidential their communications with their clients, and to “preserve the secrets” of their clients. And because those charged with a crime have a right under both the US and Indiana constitutions to the effective assistance of an attorney, the communications between an attorney and their client on legal matters are generally protected from being disclosed to third parties – including to law enforcement.

When a Legal Search Sweeps Up Confidential Communications

When police gather evidence during a legal search, they typically do not have the time or the ability to closely review everything they take. As a result, it is not unusual for legal searches to result in the seizure of documents and data that include privileged communications between the defendant and their attorney.

When that happens, the defendant’s attorney can ask the judge for an order appointing an independent third party (sometimes called a “special master”) to review and filter out privileged communications and legal advice from the evidence collected during the search.

When there are a lot of documents or data to review, this can sometimes lead to a “filter team” working with specialized search apps to review the seized information and segregate out the potentially privileged information. A “privilege log” or list will be created so that the judge in the case can ultimately rule on whether any of the documents or data on that list should be available for review by prosecutors.

It is important to move quickly if you suspect that police have seized privileged information. The faster that your attorney can request that the information be isolated and reviewed for privilege, the less likely it is that prosecutors will “accidentally” learn of the questions you’ve asked your attorney and the advice you’ve received in response.

Exceptions to the Privilege

Because the attorney-client privilege is so strong, there are exceptions to it. In criminal cases, the privilege can be broken if:

  • The attorney-client communications or attorney advice is disclosed to a third party
  • The attorney is involved in crime or fraud with the client

It’s important not to share any attorney advice you receive with third parties; if you feel the need to do so, check with your attorney first.

Razumich & Associates Can Protect Your Privileged Communications

If you are the target of a search warrant and your communications with your attorney are seized by law enforcement, Razumich & Associates can help you protect that from disclosure. Our experienced attorneys understand the standards that courts in Indiana apply to determining whether a document or other information is protected by the attorney-client privilege. We know the steps to take to quickly assert that privilege and keep it from being disclosed to and used by law enforcement and prosecutors.

Call Razumich & Associates today at 317-983-5333, or reach out to us online if your confidential communications with your attorney have been seized in a search. We are ready to fight for your rights and protect your privileged information!

Let Us Help You
WIN Your Case!

Call Us Today! Available 24/7


Your Freedom Depend On This!
Schedule Your Free Case Evaluation Now!

No Obligation. No Strings Attached. No Cost.